Everyone
Cases of interest: September 2026
A summary of interesting or topical employment cases in September 2026.
Postal Workers Union of Aotearoa Inc v New Zealand Post Ltd [2026] NZEmpC 218
Employment Court – Employment status – Courier drivers
At issue was whether 3 courier drivers were employees of New Zealand Post.
3 delivery partners (drivers) had contracting agreements with New Zealand Post to provide courier services. One of the drivers was a sole trader with employees of their own. The other 2 drivers provided services to New Zealand Post through companies they established and operated. The union, on behalf of the 3 drivers, sought declarations that the drivers were employees of New Zealand Post.
The union submitted that New Zealand Post exerted significant and disproportionate levels of control over the drivers which went beyond what would be expected in a relationship between a principal and independent contractor. In particular, the union pointed to:
- New Zealand Post’s control over start and end times for work, as well as break times
- New Zealand Post’s ability to make changes to the delivery routes with little restrictions
- the limited ability of the drivers to decline work
- the requirement for the drivers to wear a uniform and display New Zealand Post branding on their vehicles.
The union also submitted that:
- the agreements contained clauses providing for a 12-monthly “performance review” and a restraint of trade; such clauses were unusual for truly commercial contracts
- the contracting agreements were “window dressing” the real nature of the relationship
- the inability of the drivers to build goodwill pointed towards an employment relationship.
New Zealand Post submitted that:
- the drivers all understood the nature of the agreements and made conscious decisions to move into contracting
- the uniforms and vehicle branding requirements were for health and safety purposes and to provide assurance to recipients of deliveries that the driver was permitted to be on the premises
- the drivers had the ability to choose how to provide courier services and were in business on their own account.
The Employment Court (the Court) noted that:
- all 3 drivers understood that they were not entering into an employment relationship (see paragraph 69)
- the way the parties operated in practice was consistent with the agreements (see paragraph 70)
- in reality, New Zealand Post did not exercise control over the drivers beyond what was necessary to ensure quality services and meet statutory duties (see paragraphs 83, 91)
- while the uniform and branding requirements suggested that the drivers were integrated into the business, such integration was limited as the drivers were not required to attend regular meetings and were not subject to supervision (see paragraphs 100, 101)
- while some factors suggested that the drivers were not in business on their own account, in practice:
- one driver had employees of their own who performed a significant part of the contracted services, it was difficult to see how they would be an employee themselves (see paragraph 115)
- the second driver was able to profit by delivering their contracted services through an employee of their business (see paragraph 117)
- the third driver structured their business and sub-contracted work; they were in the same situation (see paragraph 118)
- the absence of ability to build goodwill may point to employment status in some cases but was not determinative (see paragraph 125).
The Court declined to make a declaration that the drivers were employees (see paragraph 126).
Postal Workers Union of Aotearoa Inc v New Zealand Post Ltd [2026] NZEmpC 218(external link)
Te Aho O Te Kura Pounamu Board of Trustees v New Zealand Post Primary Teachers’ Assoc Inc [2026] NZEmpC 219
Employment Court – Contractual Interpretation – Whether lunch break included in working hours
At issue was whether a lunch break for secondary kaiako (teachers) at Te Aho O Te Kura Pounamu (Te Kura) was included within, or additional to, the working hours of the kaiako.
The collective agreement provided that:
11.2.2 Teachers are normally required to be present on the site for at least 35 of their working hours per week. These hours may be worked between 7.00am and 6.00pm daily from Monday to Friday inclusive, with a required core attendance time of 9.00am to 3.00pm. A lunch break of one hour is to be taken generally between the hours of 12.00 noon and 2.00pm (unless agreed otherwise) provided that the timing of the lunch break does not interfere with operational activities..
A part-time kaiako asked about the process for claiming extra hours they considered they had worked because lunch breaks had not been included in their working hours. Te Kura responded that the lunch break was unpaid and not included with normal working hours. The union adopted the position of the kaiako, that the lunch break was included within the working hours. The union was successful in the Employment Relations Authority (the Authority). Te Kura and the Secretary of Education challenged the Authority’s determination.
Te Kura and the Secretary of Education submitted that:
- Under the plain and ordinary meaning of the clause, the normal hours of work for the kaiako were 40 hours a week, excluding lunch breaks.
- The general requirement for kaiako to be present on site for at least 35 working hours per week indicated that they were required to work more than 35 hours per week.
- In general, kaiako did not work during breaks and were free to treat that time as their own.
- An interpretation which would require kaiako to remain on-site or to work during their lunch break would be inconsistent with the clause’s wording, the evidence of how it was applied in practice and minimum entitlements under the Employment Relations Act 2000(external link).
- The wording of the clause had not substantively changed since 1993, the union had not sought any clarification or amendments since then, even when Te Kura previously made its position clear.
The union submitted that:
- The core attendance hours were a subset of the hours required to be worked on site. The lunch break was a further subset of these hours.
- The context of the collective agreement, such as Te Kura’s responsibilities to be a good employer and to provide safe working conditions, supported the interpretation that lunch breaks were included within working hours.
- Evidence relating to subsequent conduct and the subjective belief of witnesses was not relevant; where such evidence could provide insight it must be approached with caution.
The Employment Court (the Court) found that the lunch break for secondary kaiako was additional to their working hours (see paragraph 72). In coming to this conclusion, the Court considered, among other things, that:
- The natural meaning of “hours of work” was time spent actively working (see paragraph 62).
- It is readily ascertainable that the meaning of break is a break from work (see paragraph 64).
- Secondary kaiako at face-to-face schools did not include their lunch break as part of their working hours, if Te Kura kaiako were to have fewer hours where they were actively working than other secondary kaiako this would need to be expressly provided for (see paragraph 65).
- In practice, Te Kura kaiako generally did not treat their lunch break as part of their working hours (see paragraph 70).
Gouws v Optimal Fire Ltd [2026] NZEmpC 232
Employment Court – Personal grievance – Unjustified dismissal – Company director
At issue was whether 2 employees:
- were unjustifiably disadvantaged
- were unjustifiably dismissed
- misappropriated money from the employer and breached their employment agreements.
The first employee was a director and shareholder of the employer from its inception. The second employee was their wife. The directors managed the income from the business informally. The income was distributed by way of salary and other payments to the directors. The remainder was paid to their family members and to companies controlled by the directors to charge consultancy fees for services provided to the employer.
The employer developed concerns that the employees improperly used company money for personal expenses. It suspended the employees and gave them lists of transactions which it stated were of concern. This included concerns over some transactions charged to the employees’ consultancy company. The first employee stated that they had a large credit owed to them as there were times that they deferred receiving salary payments or other entitlements when other directors did not. The employees also provided a loan to the employer through their consultancy company which was unpaid. The employees requested further information from the employer, the employer largely declined to provide the information sought.
The employer dismissed the employees for serious misconduct. The employees claimed that they were unjustifiably disadvantaged by being suspended without notice and that they were unjustifiably dismissed. The employer counterclaimed on the basis that the employees had misappropriated money and sought damages of $280,056.18.
The employees submitted that:
- The transactions were legitimate and to set-off money that the company owed to them.
- The other directors also incurred personal expenses which were paid by the employer.
- The information they requested from the employer may have supported their explanations, but they were denied the opportunity to properly respond to the employer’s concerns.
- It was not reasonable for the employer to reject their explanations without comparing their actions to those of the other directors.
The employer denied that the employees’ conduct mirrored that of the other directors and submitted that:
- The first employee had signed a financial statement to confirm that they did not have a credit balance, their explanation that they were owed money was not credible.
- Even if the employees were owed money, they had not requested a financial reconciliation and were not released from their obligation to obtain approval before spending the company’s money.
- Where the employees did not respond to specific concerns raised, it was free to draw its own conclusions in the absence of any adequate response.
The Employment Court (the Court) found that the employees were unjustifiably disadvantaged and unjustifiably dismissed (see paragraphs 75, 169). In concluding that the employer had acted unjustifiably, the Court considered that:
- There were no circumstances which suggested that the employer needed to suspend the employees before giving them an opportunity to provide feedback (see paragraph 74).
- The employer’s refusal to provide the requested information deprived the employees of the chance to provide a fully informed response, particularly where such information may have allowed them to support their explanations for the transactions (see paragraph 105).
- While the first employee did sign the financial statements to acknowledge their account balance, in reality they had a significant credit balance for allowances not taken (see paragraph 138).
- The other directors also had personal expenses paid for by the company (see paragraph 149).
- It could not be said that the other directors were unaware of the employees’ actions or that their actions were unapproved (see paragraph 156).
The Court declined to order permanent reinstatement, it noted that the relationship was beyond repair (see paragraph 176).
The Court ordered the employer to pay the first employee:
- compensation of $55,000 (see paragraph 185)
- lost remuneration of $23,076.90 (see paragraph 186)
- lost remuneration (to be quantified) for the loss of use of company entitlements and other benefits (see paragraph 187)
- arrears for holiday pay which was wrongly deducted by the employer but not yet quantified (see paragraphs 202, 203).
The Court ordered the employer to pay the second employee:
- compensation of $50,000 (see paragraph 193)
- lost remuneration of $59,575.02 (see paragraph 194)
- arrears for holiday pay which was wrongly deducted by the employer but not yet quantified (see paragraphs 202, 203).
The Court noted that in light of its earlier findings, the employees had not breached their employment agreements or the duty of good faith, the employer’s counterclaim was unsuccessful (see paragraph 206).
Labour Inspector v Huynh [2026] NZERA 712
Employment Relations Authority – Minimum employment standards breaches – Persons involved
At issue was whether 4 persons aided and abetted breaches of minimum employment standards.
The Labour Inspector conducted a site visit to the employer’s nail salon as part of a proactive check on Accredited Employers. The Labour Inspector had significant concerns and filed proceedings in the Employment Relations Authority (the Authority) on behalf of 12 former employees. It claimed that the employer:
- failed to pay employees’ minimum entitlements
- unlawfully deducted amounts from the employees’ wages
- requested unlawful premiums in exchange for employment.
The Labour Inspector named 4 other respondents to the proceedings who were family members of the employer or otherwise associated with the employer. After the Authority’s investigation meeting the employer was adjudicated bankrupt. Under section 76(1) of the Insolvency Act 2006(external link), proceedings against the employer could not continue. The Labour Inspector continued its claims against the other named respondents; it alleged that they aided and abetted the employer’s breaches of minimum standards.
The employees claimed that before moving to New Zealand to commence employment, they made payments to the third, fourth, and fifth respondents. The Labour Inspector claimed that these payments were unlawful premiums in exchange for employment and that the third, fourth, and fifth respondents were engaged on the employer’s behalf to seek unlawful premiums. The Labour Inspector also submitted that the second respondent, who was the manager of the nail salon, was involved with or a party to the unlawful deductions.
The employer denied requesting unlawful premiums, however they accepted that they deducted amounts from the employees’ wages for accommodation and other living expenses.
The Authority accepted that the Labour Inspector’s calculations of monies owed to the employees were correct (see paragraph 50). The Labour Inspector calculated that the employer (see paragraph 9):
- unlawfully deducted more than $16,000 from employees’ wages
- owed employees arrears totalling more than $135,000 for unpaid wages
- owed employees arrears totalling more than $32,000 for unpaid holiday entitlements.
The Authority found that to the extent any unlawful premiums were paid, such payments were for the employer and not to the other respondents (see for example paragraphs 23, 29, 39). The Authority could not consider the issue of the payments to the employer further (see for example paragraphs 26, 29, 41).
The Authority concluded that:
- The employer was the instigator of the unlawful deductions, the evidence did not indicate that any other persons were a party to the unlawful deductions (see paragraphs 51, 53).
- On the evidence before it, no other person knowingly aided or abetted the employer’s collection of the unlawful premiums (see paragraph 53).
Shaw v OJI Fibre Solutions (NZ) Ltd [2026] NZERA 673
Employment Relations Authority – Contractual interpretation – Entitlement to pay increase
At issue was whether an employee was entitled to a 7.5 per cent pay increase.
The employee started their employment on Tuesday 6 June 2023. The employee was covered by the previous collective agreement on commencing their employment.
The employer and the union were engaged in collective bargaining which resulted in a new collective agreement. The agreement stated that the terms and conditions would come into force on the first day of the pay week commencing on 5 June 2023. It provided that pay would increase by 7.5 per cent on the first day of the pay week commencing on or after 5 June 2023. Union members voted to ratify the agreement on 8 June 2023, the agreement was backdated to the 5 June 2023. The employee believed that they were entitled to the pay increase, the employer disputed this assertion as it believed the increase only applied to those employed on 5 June 2023.
The employee submitted that they were entitled to the pay increase as:
- A collective agreement cannot be in force until it is ratified, they were employed before the date the agreement was ratified.
- The collective agreement expressed the pay increase as being applicable from the beginning of the pay week on or after 5 June 2023.
- They only commenced employment on 6 June as Monday 5 June was a public holiday.
The employer disagreed and submitted that:
- The collective agreement came into force from the pay week commencing 5 June 2023, as the employee started their employment after this date the increase did not apply to them.
- Under the terms of the collective agreement, the 7.5 per cent increase was only for employees who were employed on 5 June 2023.
- The employee’s starting pay rate, which was at the higher end, included the pay increase.
The Employment Relations Authority (the Authority) considered that:
- When the employee started working, they were covered by the previous collective agreement, they continued to be covered under a collective agreement by the new one which was ratified and backdated to supersede the previous agreement (see paragraph 35).
- The plain wording reflected the agreement between the parties that the pay increase would happen during the week beginning 5 June 2023 (see paragraphs 38, 39).
- There were no added words to state that the pay increase would only apply to those who were employed on 5 June 2023 (see paragraph 38).
- There was no evidence to demonstrate that the employee’s starting pay rate included the pay increase (see paragraph 39).
The Authority found that the pay increase was to come into effect during the pay week that commenced on or after 5 June 2023 (see paragraph 40). Accordingly, the employee was entitled to the 7.5 per cent pay increase (see paragraph 42). It concluded that the employer breached the collective agreement by not offering this increase to the employee (see paragraph 42). The Authority directed the parties to resolve the matter of arrears owed between themselves (see paragraph 43).
Shaw v OJI Fibre Solutions Ltd [2026] NZERA 673(external link)