An employee can raise a personal grievance if they believe their employer has acted unfairly or unreasonably towards them.
This is covered by the Employment Relations Act 2000.
What is personal grievance
A personal grievance is a legal complaint that can be made in some situations.
An employee can raise a complaint if they were:
- unjustifiably dismissed,
- unjustifiably ‘disadvantaged’ in their employment,
- discriminated against on one of the prohibited grounds,
- sexually or racially harassed,
- bullied, or
- subjected to duress due to membership or non-membership of a union or an employees’ organisation.
A "disadvantaged" employee can include those who have:
- been given a warning, suspension, or demotion,
- had hours of work or pay changed without consultation,
- been underpaid,
- been misled by their employer,
- not had the opportunity to respond to allegations against them,
- not had a safe workplace, or
- not been informed about proposals which may affect their employment.
How to raise personal grievance
There are various ways in which an employee could raise a personal grievance.
Raise a personal grievance with your employer
Employees should first talk to their employer to resolve problems. Trying to resolve the problem informally first can help to keep the employment relationship positive.
Communicate in writing to the employer to tell them about personal grievance and request a meeting to resolve the issue.
The employee must clearly state what their complaint is and the reasons why they believe that they have a grievance. It is best practice to do this in a letter or email to make sure that everything that needs to be is included, to present your case.
The employee must give enough detail about the problem for the employer to respond to the issues.
The employee should keep a copy of their letter or email for reference. If the employee raises the grievance verbally, both the employer and employee should take notes of what was said in case there is a dispute later.
If an employee doesn’t raise the grievance clearly enough, or in enough detail, it may mean that they are unable to take legal action.
The parties could either try to resolve the issues between themselves, or have the meeting attended by a mediator, eg from the employment mediation service or a private mediator.
Request mediation for personal grievance
If you decide you need mediation, you can use the free Employment Mediation Services. You do not need a lawyer to go to mediation.
Mediation is where an independent person called a mediator helps an employee and an employer resolve an employment relationship problem in a semi-formal and confidential environment.
If you want to go to mediation but you're not comfortable talking to your employer first (or anyone else in your organisation) because of the type of behaviour (bullying, discrimination or harassment) or person you're complaining about, you'll be able to apply directly for mediation.
Make a personal grievance claim with the Employment Relations Authority (ERA)
The ERA is an independent organisation that sits below the Employment Court. The ERA’s process is more formal than mediation but less formal than the Employment Court.
The ERA helps to resolve employment relationship problems by looking into the facts and making a decision based on the merits of the case, not on technicalities
An employee can make a personal grievance claim with the ERA if they believe their employer has acted in an unfair or unreasonable manner without having to discuss it with their employer or going to mediation.
If you haven’t tried using mediation to solve your problem, the ERA may suggest you try mediation. Even if you have tried mediation, the ERA may suggest trying mediation again, if they feel it might solve the problem.
To make a claim, follow the steps on the ERA website.
Employees have 90 days to raise a personal grievance
A personal grievance must be raised with the employer within 90 days of when the personal grievance arose or first came to the employee's attention (whichever is the later).
For example, if any employee is fired they have 90 days from the end of their employment to raise their grievance.
Raising a grievance after the end of the 90-day notice period
An employee may raise a personal grievance after the notice period if the employer agrees.
If the employer doesn’t agree, the employee can ask the ERA if they can raise a personal grievance. An employee can only do this if they prove the delay was due to exceptional circumstances.
Exceptional circumstance examples can include:
- the employee's representative failing to raise the grievance in time
- the employee being unable to raise a grievance to due health issues caused by the problem
- the employment agreement not explaining services available for resolving problems, or stating the 90-day notice period
- if the employer failed to provide a reason for a dismissal when asked to
Starting proceedings after raising a personal grievance
Employees have three years to begin proceedings in the ERA after it was first raised with the employer.
After the three-year period has passed, an employee needs permission from the ERA, and this is very rarely granted.
Raising a personal grievance on a Triangular Employment relationship
The Employment Relations (Triangular Employment) Amendment Act passed on 26 June 2019 and will come into force in mid-2020.
Employees in a triangular employment relationship are employees of one employer but work for another business or organisation (a third party) e.g. under a labour hire model or via a recruitment agency.
Currently, employees can only bring a personal grievance against their employer, and the third party they work for cannot be added to the claim.
The new law will mean that a third party, i.e. the organisation or business that the worker is actually doing the work for can be added to a personal grievance claim (in cases where the behaviour or actions of the third party contributed to the problem). Under the new law, effective in mid-2020, the employer and the third party could both potentially be responsible for providing remedies to the employee.
Tools and Resources
Raising a personal grievance sample letter - DOC 27KB
Use this example to help raise a personal grievance with an employer.
Subscribe to our email newsletter
Receive news and updates each month from Employment New Zealand.